On July 9, 2024, former Pennsylvania State Police Commissioner Paul Evanko passed away. Evanko served as commissioner from 1995 to 2003, a period marked by both significant achievements and public controversies.

This blog post will explore Evanko’s career, focusing on his leadership of the Pennsylvania State Police, his record on drunk driving enforcement, and the later controversies that shadowed his legacy.

Early Life and Career

Born in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, Paul Evanko dedicated his life to law enforcement. After graduating from Millersville University, he joined the Pennsylvania State Police in the early 1970s. Rising through the ranks, Evanko gained a reputation for competence and dedication.

In 1995, then-Governor Tom Ridge appointed Evanko as the 17th Commissioner of the Pennsylvania State Police. This marked the beginning of a pivotal period in Evanko’s career and the history of the state police force.

Focus on DUI Enforcement

One of Evanko’s signature initiatives as commissioner was his focus on combating drunk driving. During his tenure, DUI arrests reached record highs. Evanko implemented stricter enforcement measures and launched public awareness campaigns highlighting the dangers of driving under the influence.

These efforts were credited with a significant reduction in drunk driving fatalities on Pennsylvania roadways. Evanko’s strong stance against DUI earned him praise from public safety advocates and solidified his image as a leader committed to protecting the lives of Pennsylvanians.

Leadership During the 9/11 Attacks

Evanko’s leadership was also tested on the national stage during the tragic events of September 11th, 2001. When United Flight 93 crashed in Shanksville, Pennsylvania, the Pennsylvania State Police played a crucial role in securing the crash site and initiating the investigation.

Evanko’s actions during this crisis demonstrated his commitment to public safety and his ability to lead in the face of unprecedented adversity. He later donated his handwritten notes from that day to the Pennsylvania State Archives, providing a valuable historical account of the state police response on 9/11.

Later Controversies

However, Evanko’s legacy is not without its blemishes. In 2004, a civil lawsuit was filed against him and the Pennsylvania State Police regarding the handling of sexual misconduct cases within the force. The lawsuit focused specifically on the actions of former trooper Michael Evans, who was accused of assaulting several women during the 1990s.

Critics argued that Evanko failed to take appropriate action against Evans and that the department had a culture that minimized or ignored sexual misconduct allegations. This lawsuit tarnished Evanko’s reputation and raised questions about his leadership.

DUI Arrest

Perhaps the most public controversy surrounding Evanko came in 2007. He was arrested for driving under the influence after a car accident. This incident stood in stark contrast to his previous stance against drunk driving, leading to significant public criticism.

The arrest raised questions about Evanko’s personal judgment and damaged the credibility of his anti-DUI efforts. It served as a stark reminder of the importance of upholding the law, even for those tasked with enforcing it.

A Complex Legacy

Paul Evanko’s legacy as Pennsylvania State Police Commissioner is complex and multifaceted. He is credited with leading the force through a period of significant achievement, particularly in drunk driving enforcement.

However, the later controversies surrounding sexual misconduct allegations and his own DUI arrest cast a shadow over his accomplishments. Evanko’s story reminds us that leadership is a journey with both successes and failures.

Looking Forward

The Pennsylvania State Police continues to evolve under new leadership. The force is committed to addressing past mistakes and upholding the highest standards of conduct. Evanko’s legacy serves as a reminder of the importance of both progress and accountability in law enforcement.

This blog post has aimed to provide a balanced perspective on Paul Evanko’s career.